Monday, September 16, 2013

In chapter 2 we see the parents reluctantly giving Petey up after trying absolutely everything they could to care for and help their son.  When Petey arrives in Warm Springs, MT, he is met with a completely different attitude.  Compare and contrast the feelings and emotions of Petey's parents to that of the admitting doctor.  Can you explain why each party may have had the approach they did to Petey?


8 comments:

  1. The difference between the parents and the doctor is that the parents were happy to get Petey and to take care of him, mostly because they were his parents and they loved him. But the doctor was less excited to get Petey, and didn't enjoy taking care of him. I think the parents actually cared about Petey and saw him as a child, whereas the staff at Warm Springs saw him as just another patient that needed taking care of.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Petey's parents truly loved him and couldn't accept the fact that he was not normal. This drove them to try everything they could to help him. When their money ran out, they had no other choice but to give him up. The doctors thought that he couldn't think so it didn't matter whether or not they were not nice to him. He was just another "messed up child" that they had to deal with.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that is is very true that Petey's parent wanted a "normal" kid. They wanted him to be able to play with his siblings and participate in life like most other people. I also think that if they had kept him longer instead of giving him to Warm Springs that they would have realized that Petey was not just a "messed up" kid and that he could think and communicate, even though it is different from us. I agree that the doctors thought of Petey as another messed up child, although he was so much more than that!

      Delete
  4. Petey's parents were heartbroken when they had to leave him at Warm Springs. Even though they thought that he would be well cared for, they still didn't want to leave him because he was their son and they would never see him again. The doctors, nurses, and other people that worked at Warm Springs didn't really care about Petey because they see kids like that every day and thought that he was just another “idiot.” They saw him as another handicapped kid that wasn't good enough to last in society. The doctor also thought that Sarah Corbin was being dramatic and unrealistic by hoping that they could fix Petey or that he wasn't as bad as they thought he was.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think you did very well in describing the feelings of both the parents and staff. I agree with the points that you made in this paragraph. Also, you did especially well in describing how the staff felt about Petey and the other children at Warm Springs.

      Delete
  5. There are many differences to the views of Petey. His parents loved him and they didn't want to let him go. It isn't a surprise they felt this way. After all, he is their son. The doctor at Warm Springs felt differently. He didn't care at all about Petey. The doctor just thought he was just another kid that couldn't think or talk or many things that comes natural to us. The doctor sees multiple kids like that. It is kind of sad to see he feels that way. Petey was a human just like all of us.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with you. Everyone is a human being and deserves all the rights of a human being.
      Petey wasn't being treated fairly like he should have been. It wasn't his fault that he was not quite the same as everyone else.

      Delete