I am not sure many of us ever think of life except through our own eyes. Hopefully while working with this story, you have had a chance to look at life a little more through the eyes of someone who struggles with even the easiest of tasks. Think also about Petey who essentially could do absolutely nothing for himself. Do these people have value? If so, what and why? If not, why not?
How would your life be altered if you were to have to experience it from Charlie's point of view?
How about Petey's?
How would you describe Charlie or Petey to someone else? Could you enjoy being friends with either one of these? Elaborate.
People like Charlie and Petey definitely have value. They are valuable to the people around them in how they affect their friends and family. Charlie probably helped a lot of people by showing that these operations were not safe nor efficient enough to be done as an actual process on normal people. Petey helped people like Trevor make friends and he also helped Calvin by being someone to talk to at the ward.
ReplyDeleteMy life would be very altered if I were in either of these people's shoes. Two big things in my life are academics and athletics, and if I was like Charlie, then I wouldn't be able to be as successful in school as I am, and if I was Petey, then sports would be impossible. Either way, life for me wouldn't even resemble how it is now.
If I had to describe Charlie and Petey to other people, I would say they are normal people, with not so normal situations. Petey really was a normal guy, except his body just wasn't fully functional. He still had feelings, and he still had friends, he just couldn't talk or run and jump with people like others can. Charlie was a pretty normal man, but he just wasn't as smart as most people. He still went to work, he still went out with people, but doing things like reading and writing were just more of a struggle for him.
To be completely honest, I think being friends with either of these two would be hard. I wouldn't despise or think less of them, I just think it would be hard getting used to things that I could and couldn't do. I think if I were around them for a longer period, then I would enjoy it more, but right at the start it would be a little challenging to stay with it. Even Trevor wouldn't have stayed with Petey if it hadn't been for the nurse at the home calling him and telling him to visit. I would get used to talking with them, it would just be a big difference.
These people absolutely have value. Both of them touched a least one person with their lives. This is worth so much to those people. They maybe aren’t normal per say but they still have God-given talents and skills. They were put on the earth for a reason, maybe its to make the world a better place for kids in Africa, or give hope to homeless people, etc. But everyone has value. Everyone has the potential to do great things.
ReplyDeleteI compare Charlie’s life to the life of a child. Sure, he had a job, a place to live on his own, and etc. but life from his point of view would be much simpler. As a little kid, life is so simple. You don’t have to worry about food, clothes, a home, that kind of thing. They are just provided for you. But as we get older, we get more freedoms and more worries that come with it. But in Charlie’s case, he kept some of those aspects of life. This would be a good thing in my eyes, but having everyone else look down on you because of your intelligence, not so good.
From Petey’s point of view in the beginning of the book, life was hopeless. Everyone he loved had gone away, disappeared, left him. I imagine that it would be very hard for him to make new friends because he would be afraid of losing them too. I bet he asked himself “why me” a lot, I know I would.
I would describe Petey and Charlie to someone else by saying that both were disabled in some way but found a way to make the most of their situations. Petey’s story ended fairly good but Charlie’s story didn’t end the greatest. But they both made a difference in someone else’s life.
It would be hard for me to have a friend like Petey or Charlie because I would be worried about what other people would think. I know I shouldn’t be worried about this but I know it would still bother me. Its sad but people cringe at the sight of “retarded people” just because their different. Its not right but its the way our society thinks of these people. But if they enjoyed the same things I do then I don’t think I would have any problem being their friend.
Petey couldn’t do much other than make a few noises to try to communicate with others. He couldn’t work or add to society through taking a job position, but he still made his community a better place. Petey changed Trevor’s life for the better. He made Trevor realize that a better way to live life was to have fun, stand up for others, and to not worry. Petey was never able to participate in our world like we do, but he still had value. Others who are disabled, mentally or physically, can still make others happy and make society better.
ReplyDeleteIf my life was changed so that I could only do simple tasks like Charlie, I couldn’t do many of the activities I do today. School would become much harder, and I wouldn’t be able to keep up in any of my classes. Everything else, like music, sports, and church would turn into something nearly impossible for me to do. My friends might be a little scared of me, and I wouldn’t understand other people’s humor.
If I became like Petey, unable to communicate regularly or move around very well, my life would be totally different. Any activities I was in I would have to drop out of. I would become very dependent on other people like my parents and siblings, and I wouldn’t be able to do much for myself.
Charlie and Petey are both disabled in different ways, and sometimes they are hard to understand, but they are still people. They have emotions, just like everyone else, they are just not as developed as most people in some ways. It would be hard to be comfortable around them at first, but with time I would probably be able to talk normally and enjoy being around them.