If I was Charlie, I would not want to have the surgery if I knew what would happen. Charlie was happier before the surgery because he was very naive and didn’t understand the jokes that others made about him, but still had fun. Even though he wasn’t very smart, he loved his life and enjoyed work and school. It would be great to be a genius for a while, but that would also lead to a decline ending in death. Other people could not connect with Charlie or even have a “normal” conversation with him because of his intelligence, and he felt excluded from the rest of the world.
If I was in Charlie’s situation, I think that I would go through with the operation. I think this because it's kind of his only hope. I personally don’t like being worked on by a doctor but if its a chance to become smarter, yeah I would probably do it. And he probably didn’t think about the risks or side effects. Actually, thinking about people in society today, they try experimental drugs and vaccines without giving a second thought about what might happen to them. And sometimes they get sick or die because of it. So after thinking about that, I’m having second thoughts about it. It’s my only hope but I do not want to be the first to try this operation. So I’m pretty torn on this one.
I would not want to go through with the surgery. Charlie was so happy with who he was before the surgery, he couldn't read or write that well, but he was optimistic. He still had his "friends" at work, even though they treated him poorly, but he hadn't noticed until he went through with the surgery. Looking at it from a normal perspective, I wouldn't want people looking at me and laughing like they did to Charlie, that's just mean. But he also didn't notice that, and he was happy with who he was. I feel like having the surgery was only showing Charlie what all he was missing out on in a regular life. Without the surgery, he wouldn't have known how much he didn't know. But after the surgery, he couldn't just forget the things that he had learned, he just couldn't understand them. He still knew that at one point he understood them, he just couldn't anymore. I think that is much more depressing, frustrating, and angering than not knowing any of it in the first place. I would much rather just be happy with life as it is, not knowing what all I couldn't learn, than knowing I should be able to learn something but couldn't. I also understand the positives of it, he was smart for a while after all, but I just don't think they outweigh all of the negative things that would come out of it. Charlie was much happier at the beginning of the story than at the end, and I feel like that's how I would be too.
If I were Charlie and I knew everything that would happen after the surgery I would not go through with it. First of all it would be very frustrating to know that you learned so much and you no longer remember any of it. Also before the surgery Charlie was a happy person. He wanted to be smart and he was trying by going to night school. Other than that he went to work and enjoyed it. He also laughed at jokes (although they were mean ones about him) with his coworkers. After the surgery he felt miserable. He knew what he could one do and he could no longer do it. Also if I knew what all would happen with the surgery, I'd be thinking "what's it worth". I would not have the surgery if I knew all the consequences.
If I was Charlie, I would not want to have the surgery if I knew what would happen. Charlie was happier before the surgery because he was very naive and didn’t understand the jokes that others made about him, but still had fun. Even though he wasn’t very smart, he loved his life and enjoyed work and school. It would be great to be a genius for a while, but that would also lead to a decline ending in death. Other people could not connect with Charlie or even have a “normal” conversation with him because of his intelligence, and he felt excluded from the rest of the world.
ReplyDeleteIf I was in Charlie’s situation, I think that I would go through with the operation. I think this because it's kind of his only hope. I personally don’t like being worked on by a doctor but if its a chance to become smarter, yeah I would probably do it. And he probably didn’t think about the risks or side effects. Actually, thinking about people in society today, they try experimental drugs and vaccines without giving a second thought about what might happen to them. And sometimes they get sick or die because of it. So after thinking about that, I’m having second thoughts about it. It’s my only hope but I do not want to be the first to try this operation. So I’m pretty torn on this one.
ReplyDeleteI would not want to go through with the surgery. Charlie was so happy with who he was before the surgery, he couldn't read or write that well, but he was optimistic. He still had his "friends" at work, even though they treated him poorly, but he hadn't noticed until he went through with the surgery. Looking at it from a normal perspective, I wouldn't want people looking at me and laughing like they did to Charlie, that's just mean. But he also didn't notice that, and he was happy with who he was. I feel like having the surgery was only showing Charlie what all he was missing out on in a regular life. Without the surgery, he wouldn't have known how much he didn't know. But after the surgery, he couldn't just forget the things that he had learned, he just couldn't understand them. He still knew that at one point he understood them, he just couldn't anymore. I think that is much more depressing, frustrating, and angering than not knowing any of it in the first place. I would much rather just be happy with life as it is, not knowing what all I couldn't learn, than knowing I should be able to learn something but couldn't. I also understand the positives of it, he was smart for a while after all, but I just don't think they outweigh all of the negative things that would come out of it. Charlie was much happier at the beginning of the story than at the end, and I feel like that's how I would be too.
ReplyDeleteIf I were Charlie and I knew everything that would happen after the surgery I would not go through with it. First of all it would be very frustrating to know that you learned so much and you no longer remember any of it. Also before the surgery Charlie was a happy person. He wanted to be smart and he was trying by going to night school. Other than that he went to work and enjoyed it. He also laughed at jokes (although they were mean ones about him) with his coworkers. After the surgery he felt miserable. He knew what he could one do and he could no longer do it. Also if I knew what all would happen with the surgery, I'd be thinking "what's it worth". I would not have the surgery if I knew all the consequences.
ReplyDelete